Rust-colored stains on sinks, tubs, and toilet bowls, and orange or brown marks on white laundry, are the most common signs that your water carries dissolved iron. The stain is the iron coming out of solution once it meets air or heat. The water may look perfectly clear when it leaves the tap, which is why many homeowners miss it.

The signs to look for

Check for these signs over a few days of normal use:

Reddish-brown or rusty stains on fixtures that show up in the same spots each time. Orange or brown marks on white clothes after washing, especially when the stains appear only after a load has dried. A toilet bowl with a rust-colored ring that returns soon after you clean it. A metallic taste in the water. Water that is clear at first but turns yellow or brown after it sits in a glass for an hour or two.

Tell iron apart from other stains

Hard water leaves a white, crusty deposit, which is a different problem from rust-colored staining. Copper can leave a blue-green stain, often near pipe joints or in a sink basin. Iron stains tend to be orange or brown and to show up on light surfaces. If you are not sure which one you are seeing, that uncertainty is itself a reason to test before you buy anything.

Run two simple checks at home

First, fill a clean clear glass from the cold tap and look at it in daylight. Then set it aside for an hour and look again. If the water develops a yellow or brown tint as it sits, that is a strong sign of dissolved iron. Second, compare the cold and hot taps. If stains or color appear only on the hot side, mention that to the technician, because the water heater can add to the problem.

Get a lab test, not a guess

Home test strips are useful for a rough reading, but they are not enough to choose a treatment method. Use a state-certified or accredited lab for a full test. Ask the lab to test for iron and manganese, since manganese can cause dark brown or black staining that looks similar to iron at first glance. Ask for a copy of the report and keep it.

What to ask the company

Before you accept a recommendation, ask each company these questions:

Which tests do you run, and do they include iron, manganese, and pH? What treatment method do you recommend, and what does it remove? What happens to the system if iron levels rise or change over time? How often does the treatment media need service, and what does that service involve? Can you show me where you measured the water and how you recorded the result?

Do not commit to a unit until you have a written test result in hand and an answer for each question. A company that recommends a treatment without measuring the water first has skipped the step that matters most.